I'd like to be all cool, and introduce
this film as a French coming-of-age tale about romance, love, and
heartbreak, but let's be real. If you've heard anything at all about
“Blue is the Warmest Color,” it's that it has graphic, lesbian
sex scenes. Boy, does it! In that regard, this film is
as-advertised. It is also, however, a coming-of-age tale about
romance, love, and heartbreak, and a really good one, at that. It
would be a shame if this film were written off as soft-porn, because
it is a quietly thought-provoking film about a young woman.
Adele (Adele Exarchopoulos) is a
high-school student who doesn't know who she is yet. Her friends are
all sexually active with boys, and they encourage Adele to do the
same. She tries, but she doesn't seem to be able to make a real
physical or emotional connection with anyone. Then one day on the
street she is captivated by a girl with blue hair. Adele starts to
wonder if she is into girls, then, during a night out with a gay,
male friend, she wanders into a lesbian bar. The blue-haired girl,
Emma(Lea Seydoux), is there, and the two strike up a friendship that
turns into a passionate affair.
One of the most interesting things
about this film is how it chooses to explore class differences. Most
movies that deal with class do so with broad strokes. The
working-class people will be clearly blue-collar and crass, or the
upper-crust will be snooty and rich. “Blue is the Warmest Color”
shows how there are many more gradations of class than just upper,
middle, and lower. Emma's family is slightly upper-middle-class.
Her parents work in the humanities, and they encourage their
daughter's career as a painter. They are also aware and accepting of
the girls' lesbian relationship. Adele's parents are more slightly
lower-middle-class. They want her to do well in school, but mainly
so she can get some kind of steady work, and there is no assumption
that she will go to college. For Adele's parents, the girls hide
their relationship, making up a boyfriend for Emma who has a
practical, steady job, which gains hearty approval from Adele's
parents. These class differences are largely illustrated around the
families' dinner tables, where Emma's parents like to try different
wines and experiment with foods like fresh oysters, while Adele's
family mostly serves basic fare like spaghetti. The family homes are
pretty similar in terms of opulence, but there is a clear difference
in attitudes and expectations, a difference we have all likely
noticed among our own friends and acquaintances.
After the initial bloom of love and
lust starts to quiet down for the girls, these class differences
start to color their relationship as well. Emma's life is full of
artsy, educated, well-traveled friends, and it starts to bother her
that Adele's only ambition is to be a kindergarten teacher. In this,
I think Emma sells Adele short. Adele is a quiet girl from a
somewhat limited background, but she has a lot going on under the
surface. She is ignorant about art, but never dismissive of it. She
is open to new experiences, as is shown when she finally tries, and
enjoys, seafood, not to mention her openness to a same-sex
relationship.
Now, about those sex scenes. They
are as graphic as people say, clearly earning the NC-17 rating. This
is not a movie to watch with your parents! Fortunately, this isn't
one of those movies where the director tries to make the sex look
really artsy and ugly. The scenes are beautiful, and downright hot.
The question that has been brought up in numerous reviews and
interviews is whether these scenes are necessary to the story or are
simply exploitative. My response would be to look at other films
with similarly intense content. Did “Saving Private Ryan,” for
example, need to have such long, graphically violent battle scenes?
In the case of “Blue is the Warmest Color,” a major point of the
film is that sex and romantic love are inseparable, especially when
you are young. When you long to be with someone you love, you don't
just feel it in your heart.
4 stars out of 5