Guillermo del Toro ("The Shape of Water" "Pan's Labyrinth") is known for telling stories about
monsters, so it made sense he would tackle the Frankenstein
myth. In fact, del Toro has said that making a Frankenstein
film was long a dream of his. It took him quite a while to realize
the dream, as he started this project as far back as 2008. Almost 20
years later, he has given us what I think is the best film adaptation
yet.
Oscar Isaac
plays the titular Victor Frankenstein. Raised by a domineering father
(Charles Dance), who is a renowned surgeon, Victor loses his mother
as a child. He follows his father into medicine, determined to outdo
him and overcome death. Victor's experiments in reanimation lead him
to create a man-like creature (Jacob Elordi) from assembled body
parts. Ultimately horrified and disappointed by his creation, Victor
tries to destroy the Creature, but it escapes to wreak havoc on
Victor's life and wander a world where it doesn't belong.
I
tried reading the source material, Mary Shelley's novel, quite a few
years ago, and honestly I found it boring. Maybe the 19th-Century
Gothic writing style just isn't my thing. Maybe I would like it
better now. Really, I think this story may just make a better movie
than a book. The animation scene, for example, is barely touched on
in the novel. Shelley wasn't really that interested in how the
Creature was made, more on how he felt in an unwelcoming world. On
film, though, the scene provides spectacular visuals, whether Victor
is harnessing lightning to animate his creation, or, as in the 1994
Kenneth Branagh version, electric eels. The Creature, too, with his
enormity and his patchwork of scars, is meant to be seen,
not just described.
Still,
del Toro's “Frankenstein” is reasonably faithful to Shelley's
book, and certainly to her vision.
He maintains her narrative structure, in which Victor and the
Creature each get to tell their own side of the story. The classic
1931 version of "Frankenstein", starring Boris Karloff as the
Creature, focused heavily on the mad scientist angle. As the film
states, it was a story of “a man of science, who sought to create a
man after his own image, without reckoning upon God.” Del Toro's
film has plenty of mad science, but he fleshes out the characters'
motivations, giving Victor much more of a backstory than he has in
the book. He also fleshes out the character of Elizabeth (Mia Goth),
the brother's fiance, for whom Victor develops feelings. She is
barely an extra in the book, but del Toro turns her into a major
character. He also gives us a more sympathetic Creature than we have
seen in other versions. In every version of this story, you would
have to be a monster yourself not to feel compassion for the
Creature, but he is still murderous and fearsome. Del Toro's Creature
does kill, but he is much less of a beast.
For
my money, Guillermo del Toro and an excellent cast have brought
Shelley's novel to life better than anyone so far.
4 stars out of 5